Grace at Work mark

7 Things Every First-Time Guest Looks for on Your Church Website

Most guests visit your website before they ever visit your building. Here's what they're hoping to find, and how to make sure they find it in seconds.

Greg Dietrich

Greg Dietrich

November 14, 2026

6 min read

Before someone walks through your doors for the first time, they've almost certainly looked you up. In a few minutes on their phone, they're trying to answer one quiet question: will I feel welcome there?

Your website can answer that question with a confident yes, or leave them guessing. Here are the seven things first-time guests look for most.

01

Service Times and Location

This is the number one reason people visit a church website. Put your service times and address right on the home page, above the fold, with a link to directions.

02

What to Expect

How long is the service? What do people wear? Where should they park, and which door do they use? A short "Plan Your Visit" page removes the unknowns that keep people home.

03

Something for Their Kids

Parents are deciding for the whole family. Explain your children's ministry, how check-in works, and how you keep kids safe.

“

Pull up your website on your phone and time how long it takes to find your service times. If it's more than five seconds, a guest may give up.

The five-second test

04

Who You Are

Share what you believe in plain language, and introduce your pastors and staff with real photos. People want to recognize a friendly face when they arrive.

05

A Sermon They Can Sample

Many guests listen to a recent message before they visit. Keep your latest sermon easy to find and simple to play, with no app download or account required.

06

A Clear Next Step

Invite guests to let you know they're coming. A simple "Plan a Visit" form lets your team greet them by name, save a parking spot, or meet them at the door.

07

A Site That Works on Their Phone

Most guests will see your website on a phone. Text should be easy to read, buttons easy to tap, and pages quick to load, even on a weak signal in the parking lot.

Your Guest-Ready Checklist

Check off what your website already does well.

Greg Dietrich

Written by

Greg Dietrich

Greg leads Grace at Work, designing, building, and hosting websites for churches, ministries, and nonprofits. When not behind the computer, he serves his church as a bi-vocational elder and cheers on Philly sports teams.

Free Guest-Eye Review

We'll look at your site the way a first-time guest does and send findings within 48 hours.